I only have 6 Maybelline polishes, and here's five of them:
The sixth is the only old-style Maybelline I have. This is Two-Timer Stars:
Karen in one of a couple of swaps she and I did several years back.
I've never swatched several of these so expect to see those in the next few days. As far as a favorite, I think I'd go with Black In Mirrors - you can't really tell here but it's a sort of a blackened silver thing - more gray than actually black.
(I've been doing stash posts mostly on Mondays but if I go once-a-week on all these (many) brands I only have a few of, we'll be at this forever. So you may see them a couple of times a week, maybe even three occasionally if I get on a roll.)