This is Outlast Sangria (in the Glosstini size) and Orly Retro Red:
See here; Nouveau Cheap calls it "a neutral red" which is not really what I'm seeing now.) Anyway, it's definitely closer to red than Retro Red is. (Added: I've also seen Sangria called a jelly. It's definitely got a jelly-ish formula, at least.) Retro Red is from the Plastix collection, and it's not really a matte but it is sort of a satin finish - or I guess you could call it plasticized, like the name implies. (Have I waffled around enough about this?)
Retro Red seems to be discontinued but I did see it on Amazon. (Here's Orly's website, if you want to poke around, but a search didn't bring it up.) I notice that the Nouveau Cheap piece says Sangria was from a limited-edition collection. I don't know how long it stayed around but it's not on Cover Girl's website, either.